Sugar Plum Gary

Sugar Plum Gary returns!

A gentle-hearted “Santanist,” Sugar Plum Gary is a bushy-bearded man in jolly footie pajamas who has been haunted by the Holiday Spirit ever since he experienced the real Santa, an ancient and sinister creature more Lovecraft than Dickens. Asking simply, “Does anyone have a question about Christmas?,” Gary unfolds an evening of hilarious and twisted holiday glee that begins on the fateful night when Santa visited the Rankin Bass Home for Unfortunate Children, leaving Gary as the only survivor.

Join Seattle stand-up comedian, storyteller, and gentle weirdo Emmett Montgomery for a delightful and sometimes terrifying adventure that’s always a different show every night.

Live stream tickets available soon!

Alerts & Warnings

Sugar Plum Gary is appropriate for all ages, but only for those who no longer believe in Santa.

All audience and staff are required to wear masks in all spaces unless they are actively eating and drinking. The theatre has minimal airflow and air filtration devices, so utilizing masks maintains safety for our performers, patrons, and staff. If you have any questions, please contact boxoffice@annextheatre.org.

Emmett Montgomery as Sugar Plum Gary at Weird & Awesome with Emmett Montgomery at Annex Theatre, December 2017. Photo by Sayed Alamy / Guy Eats Octopus.